Recent Posts

Hi Everyone! We here at Wicked Island Bakery want to keep you in the loop with whats happening, whats new and all of our delicious recipes in-between!  Be sure to check in and see whats new each week!

Want daily messages about what we we are serving at Wicked Island Bakery?

Click here to subscribe to our news letter!  

November 2, 2019


Thanksgiving Menu


$24 each

* Apple Strudel

* Local Nantucket cranberry apple

* Bourbon pecan

* Classic pumpkin



Bruleè Cheesecake (with gingersnap crust).   OR   Woodbury’s Spiced Rum Cake

Also serving:

* garlic knots (6 or 12) *...

April 26, 2018

Thank you for nominating us in the following categories for Best of Nantucket 2018! Make sure to vote for us ... voting ends May 18th, 2018! Click on each category to be directed to the page for each one.

- Best bakery

- Best bread

- Best cake

- Best cookie

- Best croissant


April 7, 2018

It's official ... spring is right around the corner! And that means that our island is slowly waking up, as evidenced by the famous little yellow flowers popping up all over the island. It seems that just overnight they have all started blossoming! And with that sure s...

March 23, 2018

It's that time of year! As we head into our 6th season as Nantucket’s only all butter, all scratch, all natural bakery!! If you agree... don’t forget to vote for Wicked Island for the best in the following categories by clicking on the image above or clicking here:

- B...

March 14, 2018

This year we have the following selection of sweets & treats to make your Easter even more special! Feel free to stop in or call us at 508-901-5797 to place your order today! Please note that we will be open on Saturday, March 31st from 5:30am to 3:00pm for pickup. We...

February 14, 2018

It's official ... our February winter break is coming up! This time of year we all need a bit of a break ... and we're taking one just like everyone else - but just for one week so that our staff can enjoy some much-needed time with their friends & families during the...

February 1, 2018

Valentine’s Day is coming … are you ready?

Don’t end up in the dog house this year, place your order today to make sure that your sweetheart gets some sweets!

This year we are offering the following for pre-order:

*Please note that we will only be accepting orders until 3...

Please reload

November 2, 2019

March 19, 2019

December 5, 2018

November 2, 2018

March 14, 2018

February 1, 2018

Please reload

Please reload

Search By Tags